Group Forums >> Christian Teachers >> A retired teacher's views
A retired teacher's views
|
55 posts back to top |
Posted 7 months ago Greetings, Last spring I retired after teaching high school mathematics for thirty years in Ohio. I am now a published author! I feel this may be my new calling, to shift into a different kind of teaching mode. I would invite you to view my book synopsis: THE STAKES ARE HIGH: GOD'S WISDOM FOR OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS Dennis R. Ray, M.Ed., author BOOK: http://www.tatepublishing.com/bookstore/book.php?w=978-1-60604-233-5 AUDIO BOOK: http://www.tatepublishing.com/bookstore/book.php?w=978-1-60696-079-0 "Hate what is evil; cling to what is good. Be devoted to one another in brotherly love. Honor one another above yourselves. Never be lacking in zeal, but keep your spiritual fervor, serving the Lord. Be joyful in hope, patient in affliction, faithful in prayer. Share with God's people who are in need. Practice hospitality." ROMANS 12:9-13 "In a completely rational society, the best of us would be teachers and the rest of us would have to settle for something less, because passing civilization along from one generation to the next ought to be the highest honor and the highest responsibility anyone could have." -Lee Iacocca |
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear den1955, Given the title of your book, I'm wondering how it would be/could be taught in public schools. "By way of brief summary, the United States Supreme Court, in its exercises of constitutional interpretation, has said that officially sponsored devotional practices do not belong in public schools; that, in general, voluntary student groups devoted to religion should be treated like other student groups; that schools should not teach particular religious propositions as true but may teach about religion; that government should not, in short, sponsor particular religious views or engage in religious practices." http://press.princeton.edu/chapters/i7863.html
So, would God's wisdom include the Quran, The Torah, the Upanishads and the Veda, the Tao-te-Ching, and the Avesta, among others in addition to the Holy Bible? |
|
55 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear johnslat, One of the discussions in my book is on what the late Chief Justice William Rhenquist called "the misleading metaphor" namely, the separation of church and state. William Wilberforce wrote (about 18th century France, but it is eerily applicable to Amercia today): "Christianity has been attacked and marginalized by groups because those who profess belief have been unable to defend the faith from attacks, even though the attackers' arguments are deeply flawed." American Christians are letting the ACLU and other groups restrict and eliminate faith from areas of our lives they have no business meddling in. We Christians need to be better informed and armed to counter their arguments (deeply flawed as many of them are)! There are actually classes in Biblical art and literature and history in many schools across this country and to me that is a starting point. Getting the Word into the lives of our young people is a key. In addition we need to arm our Christian children so that they are confident in sharing their testimony with peers. While I think we all need to be more aware of the beliefs of others, done correctly it will arm us to invalidate many of their arguments against Christianity. We do not have to sponsor specific religious beliefs to get God's wisdom into the lives of young people. One concern I address is the way many Christians are withdrawing and retreating to private schools or homeschooling. We have to be the ones to come together as one to influence the lives of our youth. Franklin Graham said it this way: "For the sake of our commission to go and make disciples, I hope that Christians will not surrender the public schools. Instead let us take them back. Let's consider them a mission field." Our youth are desperate for ways to build character, establish direction for their lives and the discipline to stay on course. They also need ways to deal with respect and responsibility issues. I address all these items and more in the book. I also provide some examples of ways we adults can make an impact (without violating anyone's constitutional rights). Thanks for the reply! "In a completely rational society, the best of us would be teachers and the rest of us would have to settle for something less, because passing civilization along from one generation to the next ought to be the highest honor and the highest responsibility anyone could have." -Lee Iacocca |
|
Account Removed 0 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago I've always been puzzled why we have to talk in terms of religious reasons. Being good doesn't need the stamp of God on it. The difference between right and wrong doesn't need a psalm to make the case. Unfortunately, many use religion as a crutch. |
|
55 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Unfortunately joel, many use religion in just that way. We certainly do not have to talk in terms of religious reasons, but when you look at all the vain attempts of the educational community to come up with ways to improve the preparation and the performance of our youth it should be evident that our 'worldly wisdom' is not very successful. I have seen so many 'educational trends' come and go over my 30-yr career, it certainly seems obvious to me that we need help. Standardized testing has largely been a disaster. Forcing children into these 'cookie cutter molds' is not the answer. Sorry, but to quote a Psalm, "Unless the Lord builds a house, they labor in vain who build it," seems applicable here. (That's Psalm 127:1) Also, "The wisdom of this world is foolishness in God's sight." (1 Corinthians 3:19) After a study of God's wisdom to begin my book I am convinced that we can only benefit from applying the wisdom of God as evident in the Word to every area of our lives. I understand my task to convince others is a huge one. I do not expect everyone who reads my book to agree, but I am attempting to emulate William Wilberforce who said: "Some will undoubtedly make the objection that since I am not a theologian, I am not really qualified to address this subject. If I need to defend myself against such objection, I think it should be good enough to point out that we all have an obligation to do whatever we can to promote the welfare of our fellow man." This is my way to try to promote the welfare of the youth in our public schools. You'll find that many of my thoughts are not exclusive to Christian belief. Every parent wants their children to succeed. I just feel Christian parents can accomplish this without retreating to private or home schooling. I appreciate your reply joel! "In a completely rational society, the best of us would be teachers and the rest of us would have to settle for something less, because passing civilization along from one generation to the next ought to be the highest honor and the highest responsibility anyone could have." -Lee Iacocca |
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear dan1955, Clearly, you believe that Christianity is the one, true religion. However, in public schools there are children whose families believe otherwise.This would include children from families of other faiths as well as children from families where agnosticism or atheism is the belief of choice.So, how would you teach your Christian beliefs without offending the parents of such children. I know you said that many of your thoughts are not exclusive to Christian belief, but how many of them are inclusive to, say, atheistic belief? |
|
55 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear johnslat, I may not have given the correct impression here. Let's see if I can do better. I believe that the majority of Americans would agree that our children need to develop good character, have respect for themselves and others, and develop responsibility for their words and actions. I think they want their children to leave the public schools with a direction for their lives and the discipline to see their way beyond the distractions of this world to their goal. These concepts to me go beyond religious boundaries. What I am proposing is that these are all biblical values and we Christians can go a long way toward developing educational strategies to accomplish them. This does not mean that all students must believe the Bible to profit from these concepts. It also is not to imply that we should be preaching Christianity to all students in public schools. I do feel that if the Bible is introduced in art, literature and history classes, that exposure may reap benefits in other areas simply because I believe in the power of the Word to change lives. That would by no means be the teacher's goal, but would possibly be a side benefit. This may not completely address your questions but I am short on time for now. I hope we can continue! "In a completely rational society, the best of us would be teachers and the rest of us would have to settle for something less, because passing civilization along from one generation to the next ought to be the highest honor and the highest responsibility anyone could have." -Lee Iacocca |
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear den1955, Thank you - I hope, when you have the time, you could be a little more specific regarding the Biblical values that you refer to and the context in which they would be taught. Regards, John |
|
494 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago john, when faced with a simular problem of a student of 7th day advent. we asked the mother what she would like us todo with a birthday party a mother was throwing for her son the last 20 minutes of the day (this was a 2nd grade classroom). we gave her options of a her daughter going to the library and reading for AR points or we going to the caff. the mother chose for her daughter to go to the lib. and the party went on. the point is for years religion has been pushed around in the legal system (sense 65) and sense if you look america we have been braking down morally, would you not agree to some extent. i know our ethical code is always been flawed throughout history, but it has went down sense 1965. |
|
677 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago den1955 says ...
|
|
55 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Hi all, I'm not sure what more I can add to my last post except to clarify more. I have stated what I feel are the main values I feel a lot of our youth need to learn: respect, responsibility, character, direction, discipline, etc. Every one of these issues is dealt with in God's Word. For instance, character is doing what is right, because it is right, and doing it right. As an example, you can read accounts of the Israelites in the wilderness, their sacrificial rules etc and see that when they did the right things in the right way they enjoyed success. When they didn't, there were consequences. That's what so many of our youth need to learn. As to how do we teach this.... I certainly do not think we need to create classes in character building or biblical values or whatever. We teach these things by our expectations and by our examples. If we are united in demanding respect for ourselves and others, for taking responsibility for words and actions, and so forth, we can influence these young people in a positive way. It has to be an atmospheric change in many schools. School cannot be an extension of the street where teens speak in disrespectful and often vulgar terms. That cannot be tolerated. We all know that proper discipline is consistent and immediate. Too often teachers who have already been given the expectation to do more than simply teach their curriculum "choose their battles". It is easier to ignore an infraction and shut your door to teach than to do the right thing and correct a child, risking defiance and all of the disciplinary headaches that comes as a result of a confrontation. When that happens we all lose. We are far too inconsistent in our message to these youth. I am afraid I am rambling a bit here. Let me stop for now with this comment. The problems are very complex. As you note in many comments, the resistance is strong. Many want to complain about public education but they will do nothing to affect change. My main point is that the current system does not achieve the best for every young person in our public schools. While "No Child Left Behind" no doubt had good intentions, there are many huge flaws in it's structure and content and it is not the answer. The answer is to make education more of a priority for everyone and to get everyone involved....especially those with strong Christian values who will put God's Wisdom above the worldly wisdom of "political correctness." "In a completely rational society, the best of us would be teachers and the rest of us would have to settle for something less, because passing civilization along from one generation to the next ought to be the highest honor and the highest responsibility anyone could have." -Lee Iacocca |
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear den1955, Well, we certainly agree about NCLB. And we agree about inculcating "respect, responsibility, character, direction, discipline, etc" by example and expectations. I've been teaching for over thirty years, and I have always done my best to instill those qualities in my students. I believe I've had some success. Where we may differ is that I see no reason to bring the Israelites' sacrificial rules into the classroom, anymore than I feel the need to quote the Suras of the Quran. I have found that my best chances of achieving success are by being the best example possible and by expecting my students to do their best. |
|
494 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago John, What do you do when nothing works, and the kid is dangerous to be around, the answer is not to send them off. Getting child involved in something, even if it is a church group if contructive and works why not do it? If i have seen drug aducts and drinks change their life based on christianity then that is good, or if they change because of islam that is good. At least they are then possitive products in todays world, woundn't you agree? |
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear mrcrisp, "What do you do when nothing works, and the kid is dangerous to be around, . ." I have never had a case where "nothing works", and, believe me, I have taught in some pretty tough places: a LAP (Learning Alternatives Program - hint to the unaware: whenever you see the word "alternatives", you KNOW you're going to be in for a very tough time) in Tampa Florida. You can read about that one here: http://theapple.monster.com/topics/2691-the-best-compliment-i-have-ever... Then there was the time in Shiraz, Iran in 1978 when I had revolting (literally more than figuratively) students armed with assault rifles trying to force their way into my class and make me stop teaching. I talked them out of it by telling them what they were doing was acting just like the Shah, trying to force others to behave as they wanted. Then there was the Shiprock Alternative (there's that word again) School on the Navajo reservation in New Mexico. One of the first questions I was asked at the interview was "Do you know all the gang signs and colors?" Now those kids (seniors in high school) were REALLY tough. We had sniffer dogs in about every other week, and I had to break up an average of two fights a day. One kid was especially on my case. I finally had to take him aside and ask him what the problem was. His answer: "I just don't f******* like you, billigaana." So, I asked him what we could do about it. He suggested that we fight. I told him. "OK. but it'll have to be on a Saturday and it'll only be the two of us." What really worried me was that he might bring a gun, but I figured he was too proud to do that. Besides, he probably thought he'd whip me. I never had any more problems with him after the fight. In fact, he became kind of my bodyguard. After I left, he wrote to me for years when I was back in Saudi Arabia. Now I'm not suggesting that fighting is a good way to settle anything, but sometimes there just isn't any other way. I'm all in favor of trying just about anything to get students involved - if religion works, then that's fine, as long as religion is kept outside of the lesson plans. But I do not believe in proselytizing for ANY religion in a public school during class.
|
|
677 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago So the answer is NCLWC?
or NCLWR?
No Child Left Without Christ or No Child Left Without Religion?
|
|
494 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago No Don, What I am saying is for most regular education works, but for some it my take religion to get them on the track that we all know they sould be on. If a bully or druggy gets some form of religion and turns out to be a fine member of society would you not be happy that instead of paying their bill for prision some day they paid taxes. however, let me say does this need to be sponsored by school and the gov't the answer is no, we have a seporation of church and state for a reason, but stats do show sense 1965 and god being taken out of school crime has risen, respect for authority has fallen. Can that be argued no the numbers are there and can not be disproven. An alternitive is that there are more children in schools now that that would show a greater chance at disruptions and a lack of respect, but the numbers go up from 1965. |
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear mrcrisp, As long as religion - ANY religion - is not sponsored/'encouraged by teachers in public schools, I have no problem. But I agree with the sentiments expressed below. It's not taking religion out of school that is to blame for society's woes: "I want to comment on the statement that religion should be taught in our schools. I believe that people who blame lack of religion in schools for America's problems are pointing fingers and hiding from the truth that children are the products of their home environments.
http://melrosemirror.media.mit.edu/servlet/pluto?state=303034706167... |
|
Account Removed 0 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago I agree, religion starts in the home. I believe religion is an important part of life. No matter how many times I hear scientists say for life to be possible all that is needed are 4 basic elements (carbon, nitrogen, hydrogen, and oxygen), I always think those four elements were created by someone. Someone is to be thanked for our creation...even if you believe in Darwinism (we evolved from monkeys) the monkeys came from the same 4 elements which were created by someone. I believe tackling the task of bringing religion into society (ultimately into the home; the goal) starts with school. Isn't that where we learn everything and the birth of reform? America is a melting pot and Americans have the right of religious freedom. Then, it is our society's responsibility, including schools/curriculum, to teach religious tolerance. A good start for reading about religious tolerance: http://www.academicinfo.net/Religiontolerance.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_tolerance
|
|
Account Removed 0 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago I am in such good company with johnslat and aprilmorrison on this one. |
|
494 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago i agree john, parenting does need to change in todays world. 7 straight hours of cartoons after school i must say has hurt schools, teachers and test scores. Do teachers have the right teach religion, only if it is an elective they choose, or in the history classroom where each and every religion gets a fair shake (which for most would be impossible). The only other choice for religion in school would be an FCA chapter. |
|
677 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago mrcrisp says ...
|
|
55 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Parenting has deteriorated as the family unit has become more nonexistent. I do think that parents AND teachers need to shoulder blame. Not all the public school teachers are as professional as those of you posting here. In fact the weaker ones no doubt would not think of spending their time on such a board as this. We all can name teachers whose efforts for their students are (to be kind) less than exemplary. To me the blame for that is often weak administration. Expectations of teachers should be high but then teachers should be treated and compensated more like other so called 'professional occupations'. We need to attract and retain the best and brightest and that is an area that needs improvement. I'd be interested in everyone's opinion as to how we can reduce or eliminate things like the inappropriate relationships between teachers and students that we hear about almost weekly. Parents and teacher alike are guilty of lowering their expectations for those young people in their care. It is easier to do a math problem for a student than struggle to get them to understand what to do or to type your daughter's term paper rather than listen to her complain about it. Howard Hendricks has written, "Never do anything for a student that he is capable of doing himself. If you do you are making him an educational cripple, a pedagogical paraplegic." We have too many public school graduates who have never been shown what true learning is. Getting the grade, or in some cases just passing the course is the main concern. Learning the subject matter has less and less relevance. Expectations have to revolve around things other than some standardized testing the government creates. In Ohio when the latest "Graduation Test" was given about 5 years ago the passing score for the math portion was 40%!! That should be enough gloom and doom to stir up some replies :) We seem to know the problems out there. Where are the solutions?
"In a completely rational society, the best of us would be teachers and the rest of us would have to settle for something less, because passing civilization along from one generation to the next ought to be the highest honor and the highest responsibility anyone could have." -Lee Iacocca |
|
677 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago den1955 says ...
|
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago There are bad/incompetent/lazy parents and there are bad/incompetent/lazy teachers. They are, however, distinctly in the minority in both cases. Putting all the blame for society's ills and woes on that very small group is, I'd say, way too facile and simplistic. There are many causes for our troubles today. The best solution for us all is that (to quote Gandhi) "We must BE the change we wish to see in the world." And another, from Voltaire: "Tend your own garden." That's really the best we can do, I'd say. |
|
677 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago johnslat says ... from Voltaire:
|
|
494 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago miricle grow? make the student relize you care, and haft the battle is over. If you care what happens to them, it puts the rest of the problem on them; they have to ask the question of themselves do I care, and if the answer is no then why. We are the only one that cares in some of our students lives (i have one student that has not even been home in two weeks) so to let them know we care is truely haft the battle. |
|
677 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago I love the idea of caring as a role for teachers. I also love the idea of defining caring as assuming a student can and will. |
|
2671 posts back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago Dear dhastings, "However, we are in the position of helping to cultivate other peoples' gardens."
Well, yes - as teachers that IS how we tend our own gardens. Sorry I wasn't clear on that. |