Careers >> Browse Articles >> Education Salaries

+13

Critics Claim Teaching is a Part-Time Job at Full Pay Wages

Critics Claim Teaching is a Part-Time Job at Full Pay Wages

"To call teaching a “part-time job” and to say that we get planning days every other week just shows a lack of knowledge on your part."

Joel

Someone made a comment about my article 9 Reasons To Quit Teaching (And 10 Reasons To Stick) that got under my skin.

You should also add “part time job at full pay wages”. That’s a huge benefit, how about you take one year off from teaching and work in the real world, where you would make less money, only receive one week paid vacation, you wouldn’t be given ‘planning days’ every other week, and you would have to work on most holidays.

I think if teachers were forced to do this, they would run back to teaching and thank God they have the opportunity to teach.

This obviously got other readers going! Someone responded:

In the words of Theodore Roosevelt, “You sir, are an idiot.”

I worked in the “real world” for 4 years before I entered teaching, and so I know the ins and outs of both careers. To call teaching a “part-time job” and to say that we get planning days every other week just shows a lack of knowledge on your part.

Sure, there are pros and cons to both career paths, but in my experience, I find that teaching is a MUCH more time-consuming, stressful, physically draining job than my old corporate job. Aside from the summer vacation, I got most of the same holidays off that I do now, I got a relaxed, 1 hour+ lunch every day, and I wasn’t on my feet, in the spotlight, being watched all the time, every day.

For all the people who think teaching is just an 8 to 3 job, with 3 months paid vacation, I would invite YOU to try truly teaching for a year. And then to rip off your eloquent ending, you would run back to your job in the “real world” and thank God that you didn’t have to be a teacher.

Hallelujah — holy crap. Where’s the Tylenol?

Wow. I want to address some of his ideas here.

Quiz: Are You a Natural Leader?

QuizYou have a desire to be a principal, but do you possess the qualities of a natural leader? Find out....

I think you miss the point when you say that teachers have the opportunity to teach. Pretty much everyone has the opportunity to teach. Just as some people sacrifice years of their life to have the opportunity to litigate or operate, teachers sacrifice time to have the opportunity to teach.

Full pay wages?

There are trade-offs, of course. I make far less money than a surgeon does, or an advertising exec, or whatever. But I also get the advantage, as you point out, of having a bit of down time that many other career paths don’t have. Am I complaining about the money? Not at all. I get paid just fine.

Part time job?

Unfortunately, the “part time job” doesn’t really hold true. Lets do some math, shall we?

The math

Most teachers in Texas work 187 contract days. I will assume that someone with a “full time job” works 5 days a week 50 weeks a year. That’s something like 250 8-hour days or 2,000 hours.

As a band director, I am on a 202-day contract. I normally work from 7am to 5pm on normal school days. I also work somewhere around 12 Saturdays throughout the year with football games, marching contests, region meetings, solo & ensemble contests, all region auditions, band trips (babysitting 100+kids at an amusement park is not a vacation), and whatever else. These are not contract days. The Saturday gigs tend to be longer and AVERAGE out to around 12 hours each.

Poll: Did your teacher training program prepare you for the classroom?

Poll: Did your teacher training program prepare you for the classroom?

We also have concerts, Friday football games, band booster club meetings, PTA meetings, Open House, etc. Those average more than 4 hours of my time 15 times a year.

10 hours X 202 days = 2020 hours
12 hours X 12 days = 144 hours
4 hours X 15 days = 60 hours
TOTAL = 2,224 hours

So the band director math works out. Now let’s look at classroom teachers. Keep in mind I’m not an expert, but I’ll go based on observations.

Many classroom teachers don’t come early to let kids practice or stay after school doing sectionals or anything like that. So we’ll say they are there from 7:30 to 4:00. They do grade homework, make tests, and write lesson plans. That constitutes somewhere around 3 hours a day somewhere around 150 days a year. They also have the PTA, Open House, etc. commitments somewhere around 8 times a year.

8.5 hours X 187 days = 1,589.5 hours
3 hours X 150 days = 450
4 hours X 8 days = 32 hours
TOTAL = 2,071.5 hours

So at the very minimum, teaching is comparable to any 40-hour per week job in the number of hours worked, it just happens to be crammed into 9 and a half months rather than the luxurious 12 month schedule that most employers utilize.
And for those of us who are teachers. Enjoy spring break. And the summer vacation. And 3 day weekends. And all the other perks. Speaking of 3 day weekends, these numbers assumed that all of the “full time job” people out there don’t get any holidays or days off other than two weeks vacation a year.

Discuss Teaching Beyond Stereotypes now.

Video: What Teachers Really Make


+13
  • Sunset_max50

    ITeachtheabcs

    4 months ago

    118 comments

    These people have obviously never stepped foot in a classroom.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    belabonte

    4 months ago

    8 comments

    I was a reporter, media consultant, and freelance writer for a decade before recently returning to school to earn a teaching certificate. Though I'm still a student, when I was a reporter I covered many school districts and never met a teacher that didn't work about 60 hours a week, minimum. Some additional thoughts on the stereotype expressed by the fool who responded to you: In "the real world," when I was angry at a co-worker for failing to perform a task adequately or on time I could express that anger without remorse or penalty; in school that same anger must be suppressed and transformed into a lesson about responsibility and social values. In "the real world," I could be paid commensurate with my skill, experience, and education; as a teacher, I'm paid what the school district (i.e., the community) can afford to pay. In "the real world," vacation was a time for loafing, not a time for me to attend graduate school or catch up on paperwork. I believe I could go on forever with this, but I will end here by saying that it's distressing when people say they want the best and the brightest to teach their kids, then turn around and insult those people with ignorant statements plagiarized from undereducated talk-radio troglodytes.

  • New_pics_107_max50

    chefkris2000

    4 months ago

    2 comments

    i couldn't agree more, i have been a substitute teacher for six months now, and i am looking forward to receiving my teaching certificate during the next school year. i am currently working full time, substitute 2 days a week, will be going to class 2 evenings a week and have 4 children and a very understanding husband to prepare me the excitement and hard work involved in full-time teaching. after taking over a class for a mere 6 hours as a substitute, i always find myself exhausted and think, geez how do they do this everyday? then after i write my notes to the teacher about the student's behavior, i think, i don't have any papers to grade, lessons to write, or evening activities with the students.....my greatest admirations goes to all the teachers in this world, and i hope i can live up such high expectations.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    Miyumi

    4 months ago

    40 comments

    Metsno 1: I have long believed that the problem with the way teachers are paid is that those who do the minimum end up being paid too much (if they survive past the first couple years...) and those who do the right thing end up being paid way too little. And you're right: people are going off of what's in the contract, and not what's actually done when they assess teacher performance and teacher pay. Know what's a real shame? I've actually heard of schools where teachers get in trouble for staying behind unless it's to tutor. In other words- they have to get their work done during the school day or take it elsewhere. When I heard that, I got real mad, and I pray that I never end up teaching under that administration.

  • Carol_2005_005_max50

    cl_klavon

    4 months ago

    10 comments

    I have a unique appreciation for what teachers do, as both of my parents were educators. My father especially talked about the long hours he spent on field trips, tutoring, setting up lesson plans, grading papers, etc. My mother was stressed for many years over the way kids attitudes were changing, and not for the better. Anyone who thinks teachers only work "part time" should try it for themselves. I can tell you from my volunteer work with kids that it is a lot harder than it looks--I get worn out after only a couple of hours. I honestly don't know how full-time teachers keep going.

  • Dressy_max50

    teacher__411

    4 months ago

    140 comments

    Metsno1:
    I have to say that the majority of the teachers in my building are always early and most of us stay so late the janitors leave the lights on for us. I know that I work in a truly unique school atmosphere, but the administration has only hired the most willing and most enthusiastic staff around. We work together for the benefit of our students. Our test scores prove we do an excellent job.
    I am aware that many times this is not the norm by any means, but I will say that most of us do not take our work home- we do it before we leave.

    As for the hours discussed in this thread, some of us work overtime without overtime pay. And yes I attend many student functions and meet with parents at their convenience not mine.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    JoeZiehmer

    5 months ago

    22 comments

    I left the sales field because there are so many people who became rich off of my skills, styles, and envious that they complained and forced my techniques to change when you out sell New York you know that your doing something right. When it came down to it though it was not as rewarding as when I was a volunteer Asst. Coach for a local wrestling program. The kids are always fun to work with and respond so much better then the factory standards which we set for ourselves it is sad for me walking away from always being tops in the Districts for sales but if I can help an entire program and inspire it to be so much more like with cooperation with sales teams and adding creativity and energy that it is my own marker that Hobbesian markers, thinking, and equality in learning is still not burned out.

  • Aus-_closeup3_max50

    mmsva

    5 months ago

    2 comments

    I explain to my friends that teaching is like running a new "meeting" everyday. That's right not only are you in a "meeting" all day, but you are responsible for everything that happens in that meeting, all the supplies, activities *and* manage the behavior of you "attendees". So in a 7 period day most teachers have 2 non-teaching periods. Usually one is required as a duty time (supervise lunch, etc). If I only use the time given to me, I have 50 mins to plan, develop and prepare for 250 mins of meetings.
    And yes we get paid for time after school (45-60 mins), but it's not unusual for that time not to be *mine*. Students need extra help or are there for detention or I'm trying to make copies (with 20 other teachers). That doesn't include grading, calling parents, special ed or guidance counselor meetings.
    And you can't have a down day! In most work places after a big project is done, you have a few days to re-group, take longer lunches, filing, answering email, etc. In the "real world", if you get sick or need to take a day off, your work can wait for the next day or someone can step in and cover for you. Not as a teacher. I have to plan (even over plan) for every minute of every class for a stranger to run my "meeting". I don't know what their knowledge of my subject is. And I have to plan and prepare for the day I get back. Try crawling in before school starts with a 101 fever because your "emergency" plan won't work and you have to keep on pace with the curriculum.

    So tell me, how many of those people who say teaching is a part-time job could do that?!

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    metsno1

    6 months ago

    6 comments

    This is an incredibly interesting thread. And I guess I have a comment or two that some will likely perceive as coming from the Dark Side! But before I go down that path, let me first say that I fully recognize that teaching is just about the most difficult line of work in the world. The stress that teachers and staff experience in school settings is truly incomprehensible to most people outside of the "system." And in no way, shape, or form do I think that teachers are adequately paid. It's a true profession that should be paid on the same or higher scale than doctors, lawyers, or others.

    That being said, the ignorance of the general public is perpetuated by the presence of people in the profession who do not have the same level of dedication or skill that's being described here. I currently work as a behavior specialist in more schools than I can count, from urban to rural and everything in between. My personal experience-especially in the last five years-has been that for every teacher that is willing to do whatever it takes to meet a student's needs (off hour meetings, being open to new and different methods, contacting and communicating with parents regularly, etc.), I run into another person who thinks I'm insane if I request a 7:30 AM meeting when the "contract" states that they don't have to arrive in the building until 8:15. And that same teacher leaves the building every single day at 3:45, which is also the contracted mandatory "end time," and they will openly tell you that they do not bring work home, nor do they EVER show up for extracurricular activities involving their students. If it's not in the contract, it doesn't happen.

    Is it a majority of teachers? Of course not. And I'm only bringing it up here to try and bring some balance to the conversation. The original article that started this thread is absolutely ridiculous. That's obvious. But there seems to be an assumption in all the follow-up posts that the level of dedication and skill that you're talking about is universal among teachers everywhere.

    So in all honesty, I want to work where all of YOU who have posted here work. In a place where teachers in the building have the same level of expertise and dedication that you're so eloquently describing here! That would be an extraordinary working environment.

    In one sense, teaching is no different than any other profession. There are great teachers who are truly dedicated to what they do, and there are others who probably ought to do something else with their lives. Can any one of you honestly tell me that there aren't a few teachers in your building who don't dedicate themselves like you do? That don't have the same level of skill that you do? That don't care for their students with the same fervor that you do?

    Those are the people that are perpetuating the myths and inaccuracies elucidated in the original post. It's not you guys, who actually take the time to read websites like this so that you can participate in a community of learners to increase your skill. You're the victims of a limited number of your colleagues lack of professionalism.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    siwinskid

    6 months ago

    24 comments

    The comments by our fellow teachers only scratch the surface in response to the narrow-minded fool who thinks that teaching is a part-time job. For those of us who teach, coach, tutor, serve on school improvement committees, serve as academic improvement chairpersons...and any other avenue in the realm of teaching; we know that we DO make a difference, and at a minimal wage. Then to add (or should I say "subtract") to the complexities of teaching, we must often buy classroom supplies out of our own pockets.
    More than likely, the fool who made the comment has a child (or two) who is out-of-control in the class room...The apple doesn't fall far from the tree!
    Proof perfect: "if you let an idiot talk long enough, he'll prove himself."

  • Me_max50

    telmquist

    6 months ago

    2 comments

    I had to stop working when my twins were born and one of them was very sick. We've been in and out of hospitals for the past year and I could not put my kids through the uncertainty of a teacher gone that often. I supplemented my income by babysitting for my sister. I worked about the same hours as I did in school. I made $400 a month for one child. My average class size was 17. The math here equals about $6,800 a month or $61,200 a year. I'm ready to get paid for babysitting on a regular basis.

  • 100_0097_max50

    mrcrisp

    6 months ago

    88 comments

    Math Okay, 65 to 70 hours a week times 40 weeks a year comes out to:2600 to 2800 hours a year. For a regular job 40 hours a week for 50 weeks comes out to 2000 hours. Now who works more for less? Oh yes, we teachers (yes I am a work-aholic).

  • 100_7219_max50

    dad001

    6 months ago

    26 comments

    Preach it! Somewhere on the Internet is an article sarcastically called "Teachers get paid too much" and calculates what teachers would make if they got baby-sitters wages of $5 an hour per kid (approx 20) for 5 hours a day for about 180 days. This comes out to be $90,000 a year. I don't know any teacher that makes that much.

    Money aside, teachers contribute to society as a whole. Just imagine where we would be if we didn't have an education system with individuals who feel it is their calling to mentor to young people.

  • N26724757_37043866_3162_max50

    schult34

    6 months ago

    14 comments

    The math aspect be the objector was a great way to display how much time a teacher spends in their profession a year. But also lets not forget the simple fact that teachers are also stressed out by because they are expected to successfully make anywhere from say 10 to 200 students comprehend the material that they are expected to learn. There are also high expectations to follow precise standards, which at the upper level seem to be manageable only through tests and quizzes. There are so many expectations for teachers that I can not understand where anyone who is not an educator can make an argument that teachers are overpaid, part-time workers. Its impossible to please everyone

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    tootbump

    7 months ago

    2 comments

    Do you really have ANY IDEA what you are talking about????? I have been teaching for 25 years because it is my calling, and it is a calling only for a select and very special poplulation of which you could never be a part. Why? Because you have no passion for bringing out the very best in children who feel hopeless, unloveable, and unteachable. You have no passion for helping to shape the lives of chidren who feel they have nothing to offer. You have no passion for looking beyond dirty little hands and smelly, unclean clothes to teach them how to see mathematics, or analyze a piece of literature, or summarize the cycle of water. You have no passion for taking children from impoverished backgrounds and making them feel like they can do or become anything. You have no passion for teaching children how to read who only think about what they may eat that day, or wonder who will be there to care for them when they get home, or maybe don't even have a home. You, sir, have no idea what you are talking about. Your perceptions are quite warped, to put it mildly.

Recent Activity

Photo_user_blank_big
aonecow posted in: "Grading Papers", about 2 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
sarareid commented on: " Make the Most of an Educational Job Fair", about 3 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
sarareid commented on: "Education Jobs Thrive Despite Recession", about 3 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
sarareid commented on: " Coping With Rejection in Your Job Hunt", about 3 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
neil commented on: "15 Things I Wish I'd Known Before Becoming a Teacher", about 5 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
neil commented on: "10 Qualities of a Great Teacher", about 5 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
neil commented on: "The ABCs of Managing Money", about 5 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
neil commented on: "Loan Forgiveness for Teachers", about 5 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
neil commented on: "10 Ways to Make Extra Summer Income for Educators", about 5 hours ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
sarareid commented on: "Are You Engaged?", about 6 hours ago.